Following years of controversy and various allegations, Johnny Depp has returned to the spotlight in his upcoming film Ebenezer. Directed by Ti West (best known for his X trilogy at A24) and written by Nathaniel Halpern (Legion, Tales from the Loop), the film is a dark re-imagining of Charles Dickens’ novella A Christmas Carol. High-profile legal battles and controversies surrounding Johnny Depp caused something of a hiatus for the actor, who hasn’t had a true leading role in a big Hollywood production since 2018, when he portrayed Gellert Grindelwald in the 2018 film Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald.
Now, with the impending release of Ebenezer, the first reactions from critics and online influencers have begun to surface online. The JoBlo.com account on X posted a reaction from one of their writers, who described themselves as not being “terribly excited” about the movie, given how many adaptations of Dickens’ classic novel have already been brought to life on the big screen. However, the writer would go on to say that Ti West brings a “darker look” to the story with a new level of “sincerity.” The writer also praised Depp’s performance as the titular character, calling him cartoonish but also “more layered than the trailer would suggest.”
Film critic Lewis Powell provided the opposite reaction on X, starting that “there are no superlatives to describe how truly awful Ebenezer is.” Although the critic would commend the production design and score of West’s film, they would also call it “chaotic, mismatched, and horrifically ill-judged.” Overall, there seem to be divided reactions to the film and its creative choices, much like the various differences in opinion over Depp and his history of controversy. Film critic Phil Roberts gave a positive reaction to the movie, saying that it puts a “bold spin” on the classic story while also delivering a “sincere period piece infused with heart and despair,” while also calling Depp “magnetic throughout.”
Despite the various positive reactions from press and influencer screenings of the movie, it doesn’t seem like the studio is confident in the film receiving positive reviews. The embargo for reviews from various outlets and publications is on November 12, the same day as Thursday night preview screenings and only a day before the wide release. Depp’s most recent projects haven’t received positive reviews, though it is hard to tell if Ebenezer will join those projects. The actor’s public image has been one of great controversy, which might add to the discourse surrounding the project.
Ebenezer also stands out in Ti West’s filmography, feeling like a tonal departure from his past movies, the majority of which have been horror films. A Christmas Carol is a story that lends itself to horror elements, but overall has a lighthearted tone with its themes and messaging. It seems that West not only wants to capitalize on the unsettling nature of the ghosts that visit the titular character, but also the development of Ebenezer in a way that no previous iteration has. Overall, it will be interesting to see what the consensus on the film is once it releases in theaters later this week.



