
Bill Skarsgård has earned a reputation for playing monstrous villains ranging from Count Orlok in Nosferatu to the Deviant Kro in Eternals. Yet the one Skarsgård is best known for, and likely his most iconic role, is that of Pennywise in the It franchise. Skarsgård debuted as Pennywise in 2017’s It and reprised the role in the 2019 sequel It: Chapter Two and in the television series It: Welcome to Derry, which premiered on HBO Max in October 2025.
It: Welcome to Derry released a special bonus episode on Halloween 2026, and the series was renewed for Season 2. Because of Pennywise’s popularity and the similarities between Pennywise and the Nightmare on Elm Street reboot, Bill Skarsgård has become an audience favorite to play Freddy Krueger. However, it sounds like the actor isn’t interested in tackling another horror villain anytime soon.
On the Happy Sad Confused podcast, Josh Horowitz asked Skarsgård whether he was more hesitant about playing villains after playing so many. The actor revealed that while he enjoys playing villains, his interest has faded and it would need to be something original. He cited Freddy Krueger as a character he isn’t specifically looking to play, saying:
“For a villain, it would have to be something that felt original to me, that was something that I hadn’t done before. It’s not like, ‘Give me a shot at Freddy Krueger!’ You know what I mean? I feel kind of spent with those things. But villains can be really fun in different ways.”
This hesitancy matches Skarsgård’s prior comments about returning to play Pennywise in It: Welcome to Derry. The actor revealed to Screen Rant he was originally skeptical about reprising his star-making role in a television series because he didn’t want to “milk this one out.” Ultimately, Skarsgård decided to return after reading the scripts for It: Welcome to Derry, saying:
“I feel that, in the end, we explored some parts of Pennywise that we hadn’t seen before or hadn’t done. Andy and I always have fun together, and I think that we did those aspects of it.”
Starting in 1984, Robert Englund was the sole actor to play Freddy Krueger in seven Nightmare on Elm Street movies and the Friday the 13th crossover film, Freddy vs. Jason. That changed in 2010 when Jackie Earl Haley played the slasher in the remake of A Nightmare on Elm Street. After that movie’s poor audience reaction, the Nightmare on Elm Street franchise fell into development hell. Robert Englund reprised his role one final time in 2018 for an episode of The Goldbergs.
A Nightmare on Elm Street is now set to make its grand return with a new film. Before Paramount Pictures and Warner Bros. were under the same corporate umbrella, the studios had competing Nightmare on Elm Street movies in development. Now that Skydance owns both, the company is moving forward with Paramount Pictures’ pitch to remake Wes Craven’s original A Nightmare on Elm Street script.
The search for who will play the next Freddy Krueger might not reach James Bond levels of excitement, but it remains notable. Whoever is cast in the role will have some big shoes to fill, as Robert Englund defined the character for generations. Englund himself has suggested either Kevin Bacon or Doug Jones playing Freddy Krueger. With Skarsgård out of the running, the field is wide open.
