‘John Wick’ Director’s New 122-Minute Action Thriller Scores Big With Audiences on Rotten Tomatoes

image
image

David Leitch has always been more of an audience director than a critics’ director, which makes sense for a former stuntman who learned filmmaking by figuring out what plays in a theater rather than what plays in a review. Since co-directing the first John Wick uncredited back in 2014, he’s built a run of crowd-pleasers in Atomic Blonde, Deadpool 2, Bullet Train and The Fall Guy that generally landed with both camps.

His new film has split them wide open, as How to Rob a Bank arrived in theaters this weekend with a dismal 33% from critics, the worst Tomatometer score of Leitch’s career, yet verified audiences on Rotten Tomatoes have given it an 80% Popcornmeter rating from over 100 ratings, averaging 4 out of 5 stars. The 122-minute heist picture from Amazon MGM stars Nicholas Hoult as the leader of a Pittsburgh crew that livestreams its bank robberies, turning the heists into viral content while John C. Reilly’s veteran FBI agent and Zoë Kravitz’s software engineer work the digital trail to catch them.

Anna Sawai, Pete Davidson, Christian Slater, Young Mazino and Tati Gabrielle fill out a genuinely stacked ensemble, and Mark Bianculli’s script leans into the anti-establishment politics of its robbers more than studio movies usually dare. That seems to be exactly where critics checked out. The Rotten Tomatoes consensus reads:

“Frenetic entertainment with a lot on its mind, How to Rob a Bank fights the law but ultimately gets busted less so for its provocative ideas and more for its inability to make them cohere into a satisfying message.”

A 47-point gap between critics and audiences is unusual even by the standards of review-aggregator discourse, and the dissenting critics are worth noting too. Kyle Smith of the Wall Street Journal called it “A rare multiplex commodity: a smart and unpredictable popcorn picture.” Alison Willmore at Vulture went further on politics, writing, “Thus does mainstream cinema re-establish a comforting, corporate rectitude. Refreshingly, How to Rob a Bank steers mostly clear of this. It never stops reminding us of the righteousness of the robbers’ aims.” Reading between the lines, the split may come down to whether you want a Point Break-style romp to resolve its ideas neatly or whether the mess is part of the appeal.

The complicating factor is that the audience enthusiasm isn’t fully showing up at the register, at least not yet. The film pulled $900,000 from Thursday previews on a reported $40 to $60 million budget, with projections pointing toward a modest opening, and the B- CinemaScore sits below the Popcornmeter number. Amazon MGM moved the film off its original Labor Day date into a crowded November, and it’s now competing with Ebenezer and a still-potent Godzilla Minus Zero for attention. Word of mouth this strong could give it legs, and the eventual Prime Video landing will probably treat it well. Whether that’s enough to vindicate Leitch’s gamble is the open question heading into next weekend.

POLL

Question 1 of 3

How does the big gap between critic and audience scores for How to Rob a Bank affect your interest in seeing it?



It makes me more interested—audience love matters most to me
50.0%




It makes me less interested—low critic scores are a red flag
0.0%




It doesn’t change much—I was already planning to see it or skip it
50.0%




I mainly trust recommendations from friends or social media, not scores
0.0%