
A live-action remake of Disney’s beloved animated film Moana (2016) was always going to be a tough sell. While Disney remakes such as Snow White, Aladdin, and The Little Mermaid traffic in audience nostalgia, the original Moana came out less than 10 years ago, with Moana 2 hitting cinemas in 2024. As audiences, then, we may not be nostalgic for a franchise that has seen a major new release within the past two years.
Unfortunately, the remake didn’t end up being a theatrical goldmine, pulling in a box office gross of about $324 million. It’s not the sort of number anyone would usually sneeze at, but given the movie’s $250 million budget, industry coverage pegged the remake as an underperformer, with a Rotten Tomatoes critics’ score currently sitting at just 33 percent.
The adaptation was also widely panned by critics, with many calling it such an unimaginative copy of the 2016 original that viewers were better off watching that instead. Peter Bradshaw from The Guardian called the movie a “competent but pointless and unexciting back-to-basics live-action remake”, with the CBC declaring the production an “uncannily ugly visual experience, birthed out of an outright disrespect of the medium it’s adapting.”
POLL
Question 1 of 3
That said, Australian actress Catherine Laga’aia, for whom Moana marks her feature debut, generally impressed critics, with reviewers praising her performance and singing chops as she belted out classics like “How Far I’ll Go” and “Along The Way.” Plus, Rotten Tomatoes’ Popcornmeter, which captures audience sentiment, sits at a respectable 87 percent, suggesting this is another example of a movie where audiences are defying critics.
Moana’s Live Action Remake Finds Redemption On Streaming
There’s been a light at the end of the tunnel for the remake of Moana, with the adaptation topping Nielsen’s streaming charts for the period between October 18 and 25. During that period, the film was streamed for 579 minutes in total, beating out a number of Halloween favorites including Coraline, Hocus Pocus, and The Nightmare Before Christmas.
The reasons for the disparity in success between Moana‘s release in theaters and on streaming aren’t clear. A contributing factor may be that movies released in theaters tend to do much better on streamers than those released direct to streaming, with the New York Times reporting that some movies are given theatrical runs first for the sole purpose of creating a streaming success.
As the NYT writes, “It turns out that all the things that make theatrical movies successful — expansive marketing and public relations campaigns, and valuable word of mouth — continue to help movies perform once they land in the home.” Whatever the reasons may be, it’s clear that bombing at the box office is no longer a surefire sign that a project won’t find success, with streaming offering another avenue for movies to find their audience. Moana is now streaming on Disney+.
