New ‘Rocky’ Movie Hailed as One of the Year’s Best Crowd-Pleasers on Rotten Tomatoes

image
image

Movies about the making of movies can be a tricky sell, but I Play Rocky seems to be landing better than expected. Peter Farrelly’s film, which tells the story of Sylvester Stallone betting on himself to star in Rocky, opens in limited release today and has gotten off to a solid start with critics. It currently holds an 88% score on Rotten Tomatoes, which suggests the response is shaping up quite well. A lot of the attention is also going to Anthony Ippolito, who leads the film after previously standing out as a young Al Pacino in The Offer — a performance Farrelly reportedly admired before realizing it was him.

After premiering at TIFF in September, I Play Rocky hovered in the high 60s on the Tomatometer, with festival critics split between admiration for Ippolito and complaints about the formula around him. The score has climbed roughly twenty points since, and the opening-day notices suggest the wider critical pool simply has more patience for a crowd-pleaser than the festival circuit did. Cinemalogue‘s Todd Jorgenson called it “A lighthearted tale of artistic inspiration and creative ingenuity, the film is elevated by Ippolito’s scrappy performance that transcends mere mimicry.”

Solzy at the Movies‘ Danielle Solzman went further at 4.5/5, writing, “Much like the film that inspired it, I Play Rocky is a remarkable underdog story about believing in yourself when practically everyone else is telling you no.” Ippolito remains the consensus takeaway, which tracks with how he got the job. Nobody asked him to audition, so he filmed his own material and sent it to the production unsolicited, a move Stallone himself would presumably appreciate. Chris Joyce of Movies and Munchies gave it a perfect score, saying, “Anthony Ippolito from the very start of the film WAS Stallone. He disappears into the lead role, fearlessly capturing the look and delivery of a real-life icon with convincing passion and determination.”

The subject’s own arc with this project may be the best subplot of all. Stallone initially greeted news of the biopic with visible ambivalence, cracking at a 92NY appearance that he wasn’t dead yet and wondering aloud whether everyone was jumping the gun. Farrelly has maintained that he refused to make the film without Stallone’s sign-off on Peter Gamble’s Black List script, and after Stallone screened it alone at home, he apparently called the director immediately to say he loved it, with his wife Jennifer Flavin reportedly in tears throughout. For Farrelly, this is also a meaningful career checkpoint, his most direct return to Green Book territory since that film’s divisive Best Picture win, and the early critical reception suggests he’s found material far less politically fraught to apply the formula to. Amazon MGM moved the limited release up a week to Nov. 6, with the nationwide expansion still set for Nov.20, timed neatly to Rocky‘s fiftieth anniversary season.

POLL

Question 1 of 3