Johnny Depp Officially Returns to the Top as New Gothic Thriller Scores Big Against Record-Breaking Sci-Fi Action Epic

image
image

Hollywood comebacks tend to happen quietly or not at all, and for a while it was fair to wonder which category Johnny Depp would fall into. After the Amber Heard trial made him untouchable for major studios, his output shrank to European indies like Jeanne du Barry and his directorial effort Modi, none of which tested whether American audiences would still buy a ticket for him.

Johnny Depp Returns to the Top

Paramount decided to run that test with a gothic spin on A Christmas Carol, and the early returns suggest the answer is a qualified yes. Ebenezer took the top spot at the domestic box office on Friday, dethroning Godzilla Minus Zero and putting Depp at number one for the first time since Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald in 2018. The film started with $1.5 million in Thursday previews before a $7.1 million Friday, and it’s now pacing toward a domestic opening north of $20 million with a similar figure expected from 63 international markets.

Deadline‘s Anthony D’Alessandro framed the number against Depp’s own history, noting, “That’s around where the actor’s 2015 Black Mass ($22.6M) and 2009 Public Enemies ($25.2M) began. Sure, those were R-rated movies, but a $20M beginning for any Hollywood star-driven vehicle is surely no bah-humbug.” The movie it displaced is no pushover either. Takashi Yamazaki’s 135-minute Godzilla Minus Zero had just posted a record-shattering $31.6 million debut, the biggest opening ever for a live-action foreign-language film in North America, and it remains a strong second in its sophomore frame.

Knocking off a phenomenon like that in week one is arguably a better sign for Depp than topping a soft weekend would have been. Ti West, fresh off the X horror trilogy, directs Depp as a heavily aged-up Scrooge in what Paramount is pitching as a darker, more supernatural reading of Dickens, with Ian McKellen as Marley, Rupert Grint as Cratchit, Andrea Riseborough and Tramell Tillman as the ghosts, and Daisy Ridley and Sam Claflin rounding out the family. Critics haven’t exactly embraced it, with the film sitting at 49% on Rotten Tomatoes, but review-proof holiday counterprogramming is a real phenomenon, and Christmas movies tend to have longer legs than almost anything else in the calendar.

Ebenezer May Be Testing the Limits of a Real Hollywood Comeback

Depp reportedly took a pay cut to star, which reads as both pragmatism and a bet on his own back-end value. If the film holds through Thanksgiving and December, the industry read will probably be less about this movie specifically and more about whether Depp’s exile is functionally over. Disney has kept the Pirates question alive for years, and a profitable, star-driven number one is exactly the kind of data point that reopens those conversations.