Nicolas Cage’s ‘Madden’ Lands Jaw-Dropping Rotten Tomatoes Debut

Nicolas cage as john madden in madden

Thanksgiving is associated with turkey, parades, and football, and Amazon Prime Video is betting big on the sport with the release of Madden on Prime Video on Nov. 18, 2026. Directed by David O. Russell (The Fighter, American Hustle), Madden stars Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, John Mulaney, Sienna Miller, Joel Murray, Shane Gillis, and Miles Burris. The film follows football coach John Madden (Cage) and the development of the Madden NFL video game series.

Madden marks David O. Russell’s first film in four years, after the box-office flop of Amsterdam. The project was originally announced in 2023 with Will Ferrell set to star in the lead role. Nicolas Cage later signed on for the lead in August 2024, with filming set for 2025. The film was originally set to release on Prime Video on Thanksgiving Day, Nov. 26, 2026, but Amazon Studios bumped the release date up by a week, likely to get a head start on the holiday.

The reviews are in for Madden, and it is not looking good for Prime Video’s sports-themed biopic. Madden has debuted on Rotten Tomatoes with a very low 15% based on 13 reviews. Movie Web‘s Charles Papadopoulos gave the movie a 2.5/5 rating and said “Madden ping-pongs between prestige biopic and sports comedy, never landing on an identity.”

Owen Gleiberman at Variety was kind, saying, “It’s crafted just well enough to let you touch the buzz of Russell’s intelligence, his attraction to the high of scruffy bad behavior, and his filmmaking joy.” Though Vikram Murthi at IndieWire was far more critical of director David O. Russell’s work, giving the movie a D+ rating and writing, “The Russell who made I Heart Huckabees has long faded away, but it’s still a shame that he’s been reduced to directing one of the oddest and blandest examples of brand management in recent memory.”

The AV Club‘s Matt Donato also gave the movie a D+ and said: “It’s not like Russell fumbles on the goal line—he muffs the opening kickoff, blows his ACL, and gets carted off the field.” Keeping the football metaphors going, Jake Cole from The Associated Press gave Madden a 1.5/4 rating and said, “Again and again, it throws something against the wall and hopes it sticks. What the movie needed was a game plan.”

When it comes to the performances, David Rooney at The Hollywood Reporter was very critical, saying, “Even if I were passionate about pigskin, however, I can’t imagine getting much pleasure from this cartoonish biodrama, led by the kind of stunt acting from both principals that never lets you forget they are Giving a Performance.” In a slightly more positive review, Matthew Rudoy at Screen Rant gave Madden a 6/10 and wrote: “Both actors have fantastic chemistry that successfully makes Davis and Madden’s friendship the heart of the movie.”

Madden stands in sharp contrast to Amazon MGM’s other sports-themed movie playing during the Thanksgiving holiday, I Play Rocky. Opening in limited release on November 6 and set for a wide release on November 20, I Play Rocky has an 87% on Rotten Tomatoes based on 147 reviews. While I Play Rocky will play in theaters opposite high-profile films like Hexed, Fockers–in-Law, and The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, Madden is betting audiences will tune in to watch at home after the busy holiday.

Even then, it will be competing with Netflix’s football-related drama, The Mosquito Bowl, which debuts on November 25 and has a slightly better Rotten Tomatoes rating of 44%. In her C+ review from Consequence, writer Liz Shannon Miller wrote, “Some straight-to-streaming releases deserve more than being dumped into a New Releases feed. Madden deserves to be a Redbox exclusive, and Redbox died two years ago.”