Audiences Officially Defend Johnny Depp’s New 116-Minute Gothic Fantasy Epic From Divided Critics

Johnny depp in ebenezer

A Christmas Carol has been adapted so many times over the years that any new version probably needs something a little different to stand out. This time, it’s Johnny Depp taking on Ebenezer Scrooge, with horror director Ti West behind the camera. It’s an unusual pairing, especially given West’s work on the X trilogy, and one that seems to have produced a rather different take on Charles Dickens’ classic.

Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol opened on Nov. 12 to a mixed critical response, with some reviewers taking issue with its darker tone and changes to the source material. Audiences, however, seem to be enjoying it quite a bit more. Early verified ratings on Rotten Tomatoes have been overwhelmingly positive, creating a noticeable divide between critics and moviegoers. The disagreement is worth unpacking because both sides are arguably reacting to the same creative choices.

West, best known for the X horror trilogy with Mia Goth, has made a Victorian ghost story that actually functions as a ghost story, leaning into the macabre bones Dickens built into the original novella and that most adaptations politely sand down. Critics are divided over whether that gothic treatment serves the material or smothers its warmth. Paying customers seem to have decided it does both, and that this is the point. One verified reviewer named Jeffrey put it plainly, writing:

“Welcome back Johnny Depp! This version of A Christmas Carol is darker and grittier than the standard which makes Scrooge’s redemption all the more compelling and impactful.”

Others went in expecting camp and found something else. Jennifer W admitted, “I went into this movie expecting it to be more campy with awkward humor, and a touch macabre similar to Sweeney Todd. instead, I found myself crying in moments from the emotions brought forth. this is such a good movie.” That Sweeney Todd reference point is instructive, since this is Depp’s first real theatrical lead since the defamation trial era reshaped his career, and audiences are clearly reading the film partly as a comeback vehicle. Robin’s review leaned into the actor’s baggage affectionately, saying, “If I closed my eyes I could picture Jack Sparrow saying HumBug” while Dereck kept it to “Depp at his finest yet again.”

The supporting spirits are drawing their own praise, with Kevin singling out “Especially the ghost of Christmas present” and calling it “a perfect 10,” and Lydia noting the Marley sequence as a highlight. There’s a visible trend of viewers responding to exactly the darkness critics flagged, with Denise C’s blunt “Very dark movie. Unlike other Scrooge movies” reading as a compliment in context. Whether word of mouth translates into real box office legs through December is the open question, since holiday films live or die on repeat family viewing and this one may be too grim for that lane. But a critic-proof Christmas movie is hardly unprecedented.

POLL

Question 1 of 3

image002.jpg

Ebenezer

Release Date

November 13, 2026

Runtime

116 Minutes

Writers

Nathaniel Halpern

Producers

Emma Watts

Release Window

November 2026

Executive Producer(s)

Jason Forman, Stephen Deuters, Adam Bohling, David Reid, Pete Chiappetta, Molly Smith Metzler, Anthony Tittanegro, Ti West, Trent Luckinbill, Thad Luckinbill, Andrew Lary